I opened the door from the back room of the sports equipment store, walked up the four carpeted stairs to my boss’s office overlooking the retail space, and asked if I could do it this new way. Doug answered, “No. Do it the way I told you to do it.”

When I look back on that moment, it is easy to see I only had level one authority for that task. Level one is when there is only one right way to do it, the way you were told to do it. Period. I have nicknamed this Big Mac because there is only one way to make a Big Mac. Fast food franchises thrive because they’ve done an excellent job documenting and training pimple-faced teenagers to make and sell us food.

McDonald’s is smart enough to realize that someone may come up with a faster way to make a Big Mac. This is level two authority: the suggestion box: I’ll listen to your ideas, where the person has the authority to ask for or demonstrate a better way to do something. This is typically someone who has been in the role long enough to do it the prescribed way and spot areas for refinement. When I asked Doug, my boss, I was not this person; I was a newbie who thought I knew better.

For projects or bigger tasks that require more responsibility, the level of authority granted is often level three, but the employee assumes level four, and this misconception leads to all kinds of interesting problems. Level four means the person has 100% authority to solve the problem/run the project as they see fit; they are measured only by a successful outcome.

Typically, the mistake managers make in delegation is not saying, “Hey, when you get to this point, come and check in with me.” Level three authority is the “Trust, but Verify” level. If you don’t protect yourself as the manager and let them know they should touch base, review, or check in with you before the deadline, then the employee automatically assumes level four- carte blanche: I can do this however I want.

This becomes especially important as your business grows and you start handing off responsibility to managers, directors, and the people who make up your leadership team. Do they know what they truly have authority to make decisions as they see fit, versus what they should check in with you on, and what needs to be done a specific way because it keeps us from being sued?

Clarifying the level of authority at the time of delegation helps both parties avoid assumptions, and we all know it’s those assumptions that cost us time and money we will never get back. So don’t wait for the new person to come into your office and bug you with their newfangled approach when all you wanted was for it to be done the same way it’s always been done.

That morning in the sports store, after being told to do it “the way they always did it” by Doug. I trudged back down those carpeted steps to the warehouse part of the store, head hanging low, and got back to work. And did it the way it had always been done.

Latest posts by Gary Bernier (see all)